How Do I Stop Protecting Her Image?

In the face of evidence that she doesn’t care, he finds himself unable to stop protecting her image and believing she’s still a “good person”.

***

Dear Chump Lady,

I have been reading your work, especially Leave a Cheater, Gain a Life, and honestly, it has been one of the only things keeping me grounded.

I was in a relationship where I gave everything — my trust, my home, my future, my patience. Yet, I kept trying to understand, explain, defend, and forgive behavior that hurt me deeply. There was secrecy, comparison, emotional distance, and what felt like a complete discard.

Even after everything, I still find myself wanting to protect her image more than I protect myself.

The hardest part is that I went through almost all of it alone.

I do not have a father, and I did not want to burden my mother. I had no elder or family member to lean on. Only a few close friends knew what was happening. So while she seemed to move on and remain unaffected, I was left carrying all the confusion, grief, shame, and questions by myself.

Sometimes I feel angry. Sometimes I feel broken. And sometimes I still wonder if I somehow caused this, or if I am exaggerating because I cannot understand how someone could share my home, my life, and then become so cold.

Your words about not being the defense attorney for the person who hurt you hit me very hard. I think I have spent years trying to prove that she was secretly good, secretly sorry, secretly loyal — because accepting what happened feels unbearable.

I think what I want to ask is this:

How do you stop protecting the image of someone who never protected you?

And how do you begin to trust your own reality again when you had to survive it all alone? I feel like I am scared of my own kindness now..

Thank you for writing the truth so directly. Even when it hurts, it has made me feel less crazy and less alone.

Sincerely,

Tej

***

Dear Tej,

You have a classic Trust That They Suck problem.

Despite abundant evidence to the contrary, you don’t want to accept that she sucks.

I think I have spent years trying to prove that she was secretly good, secretly sorry, secretly loyal — because accepting what happened feels unbearable.

It’s bearable. A few bazillion of us here have borne it. You can too.

What feels unbearable is that you were in a lopsided relationship. Your love and investment weren’t reciprocated, and that feels like a mortifying waste. As if you weren’t reading the room.

Maybe you’re an idiot, Tej. (You’d be in good company. Many of us were idiots, myself included, which I why I use the pen name “Chump Lady” and not “Omnipotent Lady.”)

But what’s more likely is that you’re not an idiot. You’re a human who bonds and loved with his whole heart. And your investment in her was useful to her. So she rewarded your investment intermittently. (Which is addictive. There’s brain science about this.) Maybe she threw in some future faking and initial love bombing, and you kept trying to chase that high. And wound up bereft and befuddled when you were discarded.

Welcome to our very large club. The good news is your investment wasn’t a total waste if you learn from it.

I was in a relationship where I gave everything — my trust, my home, my future, my patience.

Healthy relationships are based on reciprocity.

You know who loves givers? Takers.

You just need to find another giver. And I don’t just mean in romantic partners, but in every aspect of life. A lot of people can fill superficial spaces, but for those exalted positions like spouse, friend, business partner, where you’re most invested and vulnerable — hold out for people who give back. Who respect and cherish you.

Intimacy is never without risk. But when things get dicey, you enforce your boundaries. Grown ups don’t get unconditional love. Healthy love comes with conditions like you can’t abuse me.

The hardest part is that I went through almost all of it alone.

You don’t have to go through this alone. We have a community here you can join.

I do not have a father, and I did not want to burden my mother. I had no elder or family member to lean on.

Going through loss can trigger grief for other losses. But listen, Tej, a lot of us don’t get parents or even close friends who understand chumpdom. It’s a particular kind of trauma. Find a trauma-informed therapist and some online peers to process all this crap. And maybe when you’re feeling less wobbly, lean on your mom. Absolutely let her know what’s going on in your life. No one requires perfection of you. You don’t have to balance this bucket of toxic slop on your head all day.

Your wise elder is out there.

Many, many — bazillions! — of people have navigated this heartache. There are many people who will support you through this suckfest. And some day when you’re healed up, you’ll be that chump friend to another guy going through this.

I’ve said this a lot over the years, but men aren’t open about being chumped the way women are. Back when Google gave me more granular information on my readership, I was shocked to discover that a third to half my readers are men, yet they account for less than 10 percent of the commentators. They lurk.

Yet, of COURSE men get chumped. Women cheat too, obviously. Chumpdom is a human problem and cheating is a universally abusive power dynamic. Now there’s a different discussion about gender, patriarchy and sexual entitlement — but getting your heart stomped on is an equal opportunity calamity.

How do you stop protecting the image of someone who never protected you?

Remember you matter.

Know your worth and get furious. Mad enough to advocate for yourself. Mad enough to notice that the Empress has no clothes. They’re wadded up behind a sofa somewhere while she’s having a furtive f*ck with a loser.

She FEELS powerful because she broke your heart. But don’t confuse that with actual worth. Real people show up meaningfully in your life. They don’t check out for affairs. Healthy adults break up ethically with the chumps they purported to have once loved. They clean up their messes. They don’t extract value from chump labor.

Am I pissing you off yet?

Consider that your values are in conflict.

Not everything is pathology.

I kept trying to understand, explain, defend, and forgive behavior that hurt me deeply.

That’s great. Good partners do this. You’ve got an internal moral compass that asks “Maybe I’m at fault here? Perhaps I should be more forgiving? Maybe I’m not looking at this situation fully?” And that’s terrific.

What’s not terrific is that all these good qualities can be weaponized against you. Dr. George Simon makes the point that you can only manipulate people who feel shame and self-reflect. FWs are impervious to shame, so manipulation (or pleas to be a Better Person) fail with them. But chumps? Oh, we’ll run in circles trying to improve ourselves to win back a FW. We will buy all those save your marriage courses. We torture ourselves with self-recriminations.

You’re not in a fair fight.

There was secrecy, comparison, emotional distance, and what felt like a complete discard.

You can’t box with a ghost.

Cheating is conducted in secret. It’s a series of UNILATERAL decisions about your relationship that you didn’t consent to. How are you supposed to negotiate with someone who UNILATERALLY changes the terms of agreements? How do you compete with an affair partner you didn’t know existed? Why would you WANT to after D-day?

Your heart is just trying to catch up with your head. Stay no contact and I promise the spell will break soon.

Not only won’t you be protecting her image, you’ll wonder what you ever saw in her. Trust that she sucks.